Why Patients Don't Follow Through on Treatment Plans, and How to Fix It

By Anne-Kathrin Eiselt, Ph.D. · Originally published on Medical Economics · October 27, 2026
A recommendation that takes a clinician a few seconds to type can hand a patient a week of quiet work: which product to buy, what it costs, whether insurance covers it, which supplier actually stocks it, and whether it will arrive in time. The clinic chart shows a care plan in place. From the patient's side, the plan has not started yet.
That disconnect is the subject of a new Medical Economics article by behavioral neuroscientist Anne-Kathrin Eiselt, Ph.D., and it lands squarely in the work T2 Flex patient access teams do every day.
Writing the order and starting treatment are two different events
Eiselt points to a study of nearly 196,000 electronic prescriptions in which 22 percent were never filled, rising to almost 30 percent for new prescriptions. Referrals, home monitoring devices, behavioral health handoffs, and medical equipment follow the same pattern. A treatment plan that never begins cannot be followed, and the gap between initiation and sustained use is where most measurement stops.
Her framing is the useful part: what gets labeled nonadherence is often better described as a design gap. The recommendation was clear to the clinician and did not account for the practical path the patient had to walk on their own.
Why reminders do not close it
When follow-through falls short, teams typically add reminders, education, or adherence counseling. Each has a role, but none of them creates an appointment slot outside work hours, an affordable device, a prior authorization, or a ride to the clinic. A nudge adds another prompt to a problem the patient already understands.
Eiselt uses the COM-B model to explain the difference: behavior depends on capability, opportunity, and motivation together. Motivation without capability or opportunity does not produce action. Research on the intention-behavior gap reaches the same conclusion. The missing ingredient is usually not willpower but the type and volume of work required.
The work a plan actually assigns
She sorts that work into three buckets, and a single discharge instruction can land in all three:
- Cognitive: interpreting instructions, comparing unfamiliar products, remembering the order of steps.
- Administrative and financial: phone calls, forms, coverage checks, copays, authorizations.
- Emotional and physical: fear about the diagnosis, perceived stigma, travel while in pain, learning to use equipment with limited dexterity.
The same instruction does not create the same burden for every patient. Pain, fatigue, disability, language, health literacy, income, transportation, digital access, and work schedules all shape what a person can absorb in a given week. Caregivers frequently absorb a large share of that work too, and health systems rarely document it as part of the plan.
Where patients drop off, and what to do about it
Eiselt recommends starting with the first few days after the recommendation, where effort meets uncertainty and no team clearly owns the step. Map the pathway from the patient's side: follow a few people from the recommendation to their first action, in their own words, and note where they pause, call someone, search, or give up for the day.
Then remove the friction closest to the decision:
- Answer the practical question at the moment of the recommendation: name a suitable product or device, where to get it, what it costs when known, and what to do first.
- When several options are clinically acceptable, say so and name the one you recommend.
- Give authorizations and follow-up steps a named owner, so the patient knows who is handling it and when to expect an update.
- Measure earlier and smaller: patient understanding, readiness to act, known barriers, and support at home.
Our take: someone has to own the days after the visit
Most of the drop-off points Eiselt describes live between departments, and that is exactly where a patient access team can make a difference. A structured outreach call a few days after a visit can confirm the prescription was filled, the device arrived, the referral appointment is on the calendar, and nothing has stalled in an authorization queue. It also surfaces the barriers no dashboard captures until the missed appointment already happened.
Recommendations become care when the practical questions get answered before the patient is left to solve them alone. That is an operational commitment, not a messaging problem, and it is one we build into every patient access program.
Anne-Kathrin Eiselt, Ph.D.
Anne-Kathrin Eiselt is a behavioral neuroscientist and founder of ThriveLogic, where she helps health care organizations improve adoption, engagement, and patient follow-through. She previously served as director of applied behavioral science at Teladoc Health and as a behavioral scientist at Bayer.
Ready to explore a partnership?
Let's Connect